Alternatives to Vacation Bible School (VBS)

A reprint of the author’s blog from April 2022 (used with permission)

Many churches still find success with doing summer Vacation Bible School (VBS), but others have seen a decline in volunteers and attendance and are searching for different ways to engage their community and church members over the summer.  I went on a hunt to try and find ways churches have successfully done this, so that we can share these ideas with each other!  I was not disappointed!   There are some wonderfully, creative people out there!

First, I’ll share with you all the ideas that I found that fall under “alternatives” to VBS.  Although, some churches said they did these events along with VBS.  But, it’s honestly up to where you are located, your facilities, your resources, etc.  You do what works for your church and community!   Personally, I LOVE VBS and it was one of my favorite things to plan all year…but, after reading some of these ideas – I may be rethinking things!  Summer is a great time to reach unchurched families (and, of course, your own families) and I would love to implement a few of these ideas! 

After sharing with you the alternatives to VBS, I’ve included at the end different names people have used for VBS.  Some wanted to get away from the “old school” name and promote it in a different way.  Others wanted to reach out to unchurched families who may not know what “VBS” is all about.  And still others said that they simply wanted to market themselves as something different because they were in an area where there were VBS’s on every street corner! 

If you’ve had success with any of these suggestions, or you have one to add, please feel free to comment at the end and share it with us!  You never know – your idea might be exactly what another church needs!

Alternatives to VBS

First off, let me preface all these ideas with this:  you need to figure out what schedule works best for your church and community.  After reading through about 100 different ideas, I realized that not only is every church and community unique, but the families that make them up are unique.  So, think about your community – do they travel a lot during the summer?  Do they hop between one VBS to another all summer?  Are they very sports oriented?  Etc.  Think about your own church families.  Do they travel a lot over the summer?  Do you they need full-day care?  Are most of the families working families?  Etc.  And lastly, look at your immediate community around you.  What are their needs?  Is there something missing you can provide?  Put all of this together and it will help you decide if you want something one day a week for a month, or a weeklong camp, or something in the evening, or in the morning, etc.  Once you have THAT decided, then you can move on to what you want to provide.  Most of the suggestions below can be tweaked to be done over one week, 3 days, every Wednesday for 6 weeks, all day Saturday, etc. 

Outdoor options have gotten increasingly popular due to health concerns.
  1.  LARGE COMMUNITY FAMILY DAY:  There were a lot of these ideas floating around.  It’s like a retreat – but just one day…and at your church.  Many churches created a theme around the day and based all their activities around it.  Others used an actual VBS curriculum and had stations for the families to participate in – but you could use the talents and gifts in your church and offer stations in that (think knitting, wood carving, storytelling, archery…whatever!).  This would be a one day event that would take place sometime over the weekend.  One church suggested live music and meals as well.
  2. FAMILY FUN NIGHTS:  This was a very popular idea that had lots of variations.  Some churches picked an evening and did it for a month, others for 6 weeks, and some ambitious churches did it the whole summer!   Depending on the time, you could provide dinner or dessert.  Then, treat the evening like it’s own VBS.  Have an opening and closing large group time, then break out into different age groups.  Some churches provided activities from birth to adult, others just for prek/elementary.  Each evening, although it could fit an over-arching theme for the summer, was it’s own stand-alone event…so if you missed one it wasn’t a big deal.  Most churches seemed to split up the families and have each age do their own thing – but I could see this being an intergenerational event as well!
  3. FAM JAM: (love the name!)  One church turned their evening VBS into a family 3-night event.  They had meals, worship, family time break out groups and then games.  Sounds fun!  As I mentioned above, this idea could be done a variety of ways – every night for a week, once a week for a month, etc.
  4. Bible Adventure Park: (think carnival meets VBS!) This sounds more like a family event then just for kids.  The event is organized like a theme park where every event area is focused on a different Bible Story (you could almost use a VBS curriculum).  There could be storytelling, games, crafts, music, etc.  Have a closing time where the entire group gets together and you can do a short message and sending.  You could also add in other games and stations that are carnival-ish – photo booth, balloon animals, face painting, etc.  You could also put out games like 9 square in the air, bounce houses, etc.  Lastly, you could tie in a mission element by telling people the entrance fee is a donation to a clothing or food bank.
  5. Backyard Bible Camp – This is a very popular model that I saw a LOT of churches doing.  I also saw mentioned that LifeWay has a curriculum for this – “On the road VBS”.  Some churches called it “Pop Up VBS”.  Ask 3-5 of your parents to host a “backyard VBS” at their house (or use various parks).  You do all the work – provide supplies, volunteers, etc – they just provide the location (and kids!).  The idea is to think strategically and plan your “pop ups” in neighborhoods that have a lot of kids.  You limit the amount of “outside” kids that can attend and concentrate on that neighborhood.
  6. Service Week/Serve and Sun– I LOVE this idea, but transportation would be a real pain with younger kids (car seats).  In addition, some of these places might be too much for younger kids to handle.  I can see this working well for older kids (maybe 2nd/3rd grade and up).  These churches take their kids out into a different place in the community every day for a week.  Nursing home, animal rescue, homeless shelter, etc.  Another option, is to look for places that are in an area where you could “chill” after serving (a park, pool, restaurant, mall, etc).  Many churches made this an all day event and served in the morning, and then did something “fun” in the afternoon (movie, zoo, swim/lake/beach, etc).  They picked one day a week for a month for their “serve and sun” days.  Or, others picked 3 times during the summer (with the hope that the kids would be able to go 1-2 times).
  7. Change your VBS to a Family style VBS – Thinking back to a couple of churches where I worked, this wouldn’t work well.  But other churches say that their families LOVE the opportunity to do something together.  So, think about your specific population and if this is something you could do (it would eliminate the need for a lot of volunteers!).  You could have a break out time where the kids, youth, and adults separate for a bit to do their “own thing” and then gather back together.
  8.  SUMMER PLAYGROUND DROPOFF – The schools in our area set up this “drop off” service every weekday at different parks around the community.  It was an all day thing (which I think, in the middle of summer, is way too hot for), but this could easily be adapted for a half day event.  I really like the idea of this one as well.  To avoid the hottest part of the day, I would do it 8-11am, and serve a light breakfast when they arrive (so parents don’t have to worry about it), and then a snack.  Parents would pick them up before lunch.  Treat it like an outdoor VBS and have songs, games, crafts, etc.  You could pick various parks throughout your city so you can get your message out to every child…or, pick the park closest to your church so you can reach the kids in your neighborhood.  The logistics would be the hardest part to this I think – you would need all of the safety information for each child, every week.  If you stayed at the same park, this might eliminate some of that as you would have repeat kids each week.  But what a wonderful outreach to the community.  (And if some families are at the park and want to join in with their kids – they could!)  One church said they had a great facility/play area on their grounds, so they set up a “snack and craft in the park” a couple times a week.  Entire families would stay and do crafts, have a snack, and play games 😊 Another church called this “Popsicles in the Park” and would bring popsicles to share while they read a Bible story, did a craft, and then played together on the playground!  Easy and fun!
  9. Skills Camp – MANY churches were doing some kind of variation on this.  Instead of planning a curriculum and finding volunteers, do the opposite and find the gifts in your church and create a curriculum around THAT!  You can offer this for a full week, throughout the summer, in the evenings – whatever!  I read about so many different skills that could be taught – sports, music, knitting, woodworking, leatherworking, cooking, nature activities, drawing, magic, etc!  If you can offer a lot of classes, it keeps the class sizes small (which helps the teacher) and helps build relationships.  You can combine this with a light meal afterwards and/or an opening/closing time when you’re altogether.  If you do a meal afterwards, kids can get up and share what they’ve learned!
  10. SPORTS CAMP/ART CAMP – This is a very popular alternative out there for VBS.  And, evidently there is a popular curriculum out there that helps you with it!  You pick whichever sports you would like, and then follow their curriculum.  Many churches balance this out with an Arts Camp (which I think is a good idea – many kids aren’t into sports).  One church decided that so many kids in their area loved to skateboard (or wanted to learn), that they held a skateboarding camp!  Way to meet the needs of your community!  They learned to skate, had a snack, learned about Jesus, skated some more, and then shared lunch together.  There is a curriculum that many churches use called Mega Sports Camp – I read mixed reviews.  I love what one church offered – in addition to the “sports” choices, they offered cheerleading and flag corps and had the local high school kids help out!  The also made their own flags 😊
  11. MUSICAL/THEATER CAMP – This is also a fun idea – especially if you know you have kids that would be interested in it!  You spend an entire week learning and rehearsing a musical and then present it on the final night!  Once church stepped this up by inviting their local High School theater department to help out!  The kids can sign up to be in the musical, help with lighting, sound, costumes, or sets!  I love it!
  12. SUNDAY CAMPS – This is an interesting idea – and I can see how it would fit well with certain churches (maybe smaller churches/growing churches/etc).  If you’re very short on volunteers, you could couple your Sunday morning (or afternoon) activities with a VBS.  A few churches actually held theirs during their Sunday school hour.  They ramped it up, had special activities, guests, tshirts, etc. and then after the church service was over, you could serve lunch for the families in attendance.  Another church held theirs right after church.  Every church that tried this said it was very successful for them and they’d be doing it again!

Alternative Names for Vacation Bible School

Laurie Juarez, Former director of children’s ministries, blogger for Christian Education (https://laurieslittlemonkeys.blogspot.com), and missionary 

Monument to Hope

Hope4CE is marking the 20th Anniversary of the events of September 11, 2001 with a recorded service of testimony and reflection found here. One the generous people who submitted a video testimony was Chef Rossi, who also blessed us with this article on her experiences, as well. You will also find a file of the adapted liturgy we used for this service at bottom of this article for use in your own faith communities. We hope you find this as meaningful as we did. (Feature Photo is of memorial at Ground Zero in New York)

On September 11th 2001 I was a twenty-something year old chef with a new, but growing catering company in New York City. It was a beautiful morning. The sun was radiant, the air crisp. I was looking forward to spending time on the roof deck. Then the world as we knew it ended.

I watched the towers burn from my roof. Then the impossible happened. Like a deck of thousands of silver cards, the first tower collapsed.

I’d never heard the sound I heard after the tower fell: thousands of people screaming.

The empty space in the sky became a monument to loss.

A few days later, I walked to South Street Seaport. The security guards at Seaman’s Church, knew me from my time catering there. They yelled, “We got a chef!”

Chef Rossi at Seaman’s Church, Ground Zero in 2001

“Send her to St. Paul’s!” A fireman shouted.

They handed me a yellow hard hat and paper mask and put me in the back of a pickup truck.

The truck made its way through police barricades, ruined cars and piles of debris. The air was so thick with dust, it felt as though it were snowing.  It stopped in front of an old church.

Two flustered women were flipping burgers on two small backyard barbecues. They were only too happy to step aside. I flipped burgers all day, into the night.

They said we fed a thousand first responders that day.

I came back the next day and the next and the next. I roped in my friend Brian to help.

On September 18th, Brian and I talked about how surreal it felt to spend Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, at Ground Zero.

As we were talking, a man in an Army uniform with a long white beard started to recite the Rosh Hashanah prayers.

We’d made it to services after all.

The Army rabbi took out a shofar from his bag.

“Te-ki-ahhh!” said the rabbi and blew.

“She-va-riiiim!” sung the rabbi and blew three pulsating blasts.

The horn’s mournful cry rose up over the burnt wreckage of the towers, the paper and dust covered tombstones in St. Paul’s cemetery and the firefighters in the tent near The Pile.

I thought of the volunteers who took turns hiding in the wreckage so the dogs that had grown despondent from days of finding no survivors could sniff them out. Everyone cheered as each volunteer was found and the German shepherd barked in glee.

I thought of the silver-haired fireman who’d driven from Cincinnati to join the bucket brigade.

“Do you know anyone who was lost?” I asked.

“We’re all brothers today,” he responded.

I looked at the empty space in the sky.

“Monument to hope.”

Chef Rossi, writer, chef, public speaker, and blogger based in New York City.

Recorded Service Link and file of liturgy from recorded service adapted from PC(USA) worship resources for the 10th anniversary of 9/11.

Picture Books in Ministry

Our Children’s Ministry Team is trying something new this summer.  We have been meeting online for over a year (as most of you have been, too).  We are going to start slowly restarting in-person worship and Sunday School.  We are requiring reservations for worship, which means not everyone will be able to come each Sunday.  This also means that the number of kids in Sunday School will be dramatically decreased, we will have a variety of ages (4-11) and we expect sporadic attendance.  We thought – this is a great time to try something a little bit more relaxed and open-ended. 

Our plan: (about 45 minutes)

  • After the Children’s Message, the kids will be dismissed with leaders to the front lawn of the church.  We will sit on foam squares, in the grass, in a circle.
  • Open with prayer and a couple, fun, camp-style songs. 
  • Introduce the book with “See, Think, Wonder” questions: show the children the cover of the book, ask what do you see?  What do you think this book is about?  What do you wonder about?”
  • Read the book. 
  • Ask a few “Wonder Questions”:  Where can we find God in this story?  What does God have to say to us through this story? How does Scripture tie-in to the story? 
  • End time together with something fun.  Chalk drawing, parachute play, bubbles, nature walk, spray bottle (water) art, hopscotch, 4-square, etc.

I asked educators and pastors to share their “best reads”, “Top 10” or “recommended titles” for this post.  I got a HUGE response.  The whole list of suggestions loaded in the “Files” on the Hope4CE Facebook Group and found below as an attachment

A couple of websites to check out:

  •  Compassionate Christianity shares their new Children & Youth Books & Resources Database. It is a searchable database of progressive books and resources.  These resources are great for ministry leaders, pastors, parents, and Sunday school teachers.  They have been classified by theme, age range, type of resource, and scripture passage to help facilitate planning.
  • Story Path from Union Presbyterian Seminary – you can search books by Revised Common Lectionary date, Scripture passage, or theme)
  • Picture Book Theology -last post was 2019 – but you can search books, authors, themes — there is A LOT of great info on this site

Why use Story Books or Picture Books to teach Sunday School?

From Picture Book Theology: (author Hanna Schock) We all learn through making connections. This very human strategy never ends. Ideas have to have something to attach to. The more attachments we can muster, the stronger the learning. Likewise, the more varied a concept’s attachments, the broader our understanding will be and the more likely we’ll be able to generalize our learning to new situations. Repetition of ideas leads to deeper learning. Strong, broad, and deep learning occurs when concepts are easily and quickly accessed in a variety of situations.

Below you’ll see the attached file curated from a variety of sources:

Whitford Recommended Books 2021

Jenni Whitford is a Certified Christian Educator in the PC(USA) and Director for Children’s Ministry at Worthington Presbyterian Church (Columbus, Ohio). She is also a member of the Hope4CE Steering Committee.

A Glimpse: What Fall Ministry Might Look Like

We’re starting a week on planning in a time of uncertainty by this reblog of another excellent post by Christine V Hides. Please share your own plans for the fall and what you are doing to prepare this summer either as a comment here or on the Facebook group page.

Christine V Hides

In the spirit of collaboration and modeling vulnerability, I am offering you a glimpse of the first iteration of our plan, designed in the shape of a teeter totter, able to pivot smoothly between gathered and online as needed. Here are the steps we took to get to our first iteration from which we will learn, adapt, and grow.

FYI,  I’m part of two upcoming planning webinars that will delve deeper into planning in these unpredictable times:

Step 1:

Remember your why. While just about everything has changed over the last few months, your ministry purpose has not. There are many ways to say it, but our purpose has always been to nurture disciples who know, love and serve God and in so doing transform our hearts, minds…

View original post 580 more words

FIG-Families In the Garden

Is your church searching for a family activity that moves slowly into an expanded social bubble while providing an opportunity for the congregation to begin to “regather” in person on your campus? Why not be a FIG and DIG?

family in the garden (003)
Children of God, of all ages, are looking for ways to connect beyond screens. Church activities have been fairly two dimensional in the last few months. Now, we are all ready to head outdoors and back to working together doing kingdom work with kingdom hands. Second Presbyterian Church is reviving one such project called FIG. The “Green Team” tends the Northside Community Garden to provide fresh fruits and vegetables to the Northside Ministry’s Food Pantry. They collaborated with the Children’s Ministries Team to include members of all ages. Three years ago, a program called “FIG” began.
“FIG” is a collaborative partnership between the Community Garden and the Children’s Ministries program. It stands for Families in the Garden.

Continue reading

Insights for Churches from Our Camps and Conference Centers

As churches consider what it will look like to offer in-person programs for children and youth, you may want to gain insight from the experiences of others. While most of our camp and conference programs were cancelled due to COVID-19, some sites are currently offering face-to-face programing this summer. Here are just some of the insights shared by our camps and conference centers:

T-shirt front that says "Six Feet Apart but Closer than Ever" and has an outline of a camp saying "Summer Camp 2020" at the bottom.

Continue reading

Connecting With Kids This Summer

We are all coming up with NEW ideas to help connect with our kids and families this summer.  We may not be able to gather in large groups, but we can still CONNECT in creative and meaningful ways.

I have gathered ideas, suggestions and try-it’s to share.

This is a start; I am sure this awesome group of Ministry Leaders/Teachers/Educators will keep adding to the list.  Most of these you can do with a small group 3-5 people or families can meet up and participate as their own small group.

 

FamilyBikeRiders

*Meet up or Drop off (limit 3-5 people and observe social distance protocols)

  • Bike Ride
  • Visit a farm – the Bible uses a lot of farming and shepherding metaphors (ask the farmer to demonstrate calling animals for feeding time or how they plant a field or to explain what gleaning is)
  • Drive-thru farm (we have a few of these in Ohio)
  • Serve at a Soup Kitchen or Homeless Shelter
  • Petting Zoo
  • BinGO – Bingo in the church parking lot. Open the back of the mini-van or SVU, sit in lawn chairs near your vehicle.  Use a bull-horn to call #’s.
  • Movie – outdoors (bring your own blanket or chairs)
  • Book Club – read a book together and discuss in person or over zoom
  • Dog Show – dress up your dog, best groomed, tricks or agility (even if you don’t have a dog, it would be fun to come and watch)
  • Hike at a local park
  • Walk and meet at smaller/less known Nature Preserves
  • Kayaking or Canoeing
  • Video – send in a 60-second video of anything – blowing a bubble from bubble gum, cup stacking, playing the piano, reciting a poem, doing a trick on their bike, burping the alphabet…etc

*Disclaimer: I wouldn’t use the church van this summer but encourage parents to meet you or drop kids off for a designated work time.  I would also encourage mask wearing.

Low Touch or No Touch Games

  • Frisbee golf (each participant brings their own frisbee, or provide cleaning wipes)
  • Bocce Ball
  • Cornhole (make up new bags using ziplock baggies, easy to wipe down)
  • BadmintonWater fight (002)
  • Capture the Flag
  • Croquet
  • Supersoakers – water fight

 

Things I have been thinking about, but not sure how to do

  • Theology on Tap with Kids — Lemonade on the Lawn?
  • Some Good News – based on John Krasinski’s SGN channel – ask people to send in short videos of people doing good things (make a compilation video to share)
  • Mission UNTRIP – serve locally – dog shelter, resale or thrift shop, food bank, community garden, etc…
  • Unwind at 9 – a meet up time with parents to check in, share fears and hopes and connect

What have you been thinking about?

What can you add to this list?

Update in the comments – share your ideas.

jenni bio pic  Jenni Whitford is a Certified Christian Educator in the PC(USA) and Director for Children’s Ministry at Worthington Presbyterian Church (Columbus, Ohio), Member of Hope4CE Steering Committee

A Time for Reflection: What are we learning?

Three months ago life as we had known it changed. Schools and church buildings closed. Stores and businesses shut down. Homes became offices for many.  We became even more aware of the “front line” workers in our communities and the risks they take to keep basic services in place.

Words and technology platforms that we used occasionally or hadn’t heard of before became part of our daily language. Many faced the realities of virtual worship: to stream or to record? Instrumental music or vocals? What tools do we need to pull it off?

Continue reading

Mother’s Day

I am a mother of two. One bright, creative, full of life five year old and her sister who lives in heaven. Mother’s Day has always been tricky for me. Don’t get me wrong. I love recognizing my mom, both of my grandmothers and the many other important “mothering” people in my life. My living child has an amazing godmother and many positive female role models but Mother’s Day is a challenge.

Continue reading

Is VBS to be part of your RE-ENTRY?

In 2020, being an “experienced” Vacation Bible School (VBS) staff or volunteer won’t automatically get you very far, at least not on the programmatic side. Nationally, Christian Educators are seeking out ‘bridge options’ to serve children and families during this between-time. They are choosing a creative mix of the virtual and the mundane. Some can be integrated into a unique, perhaps one-time (perhaps not) VBS venue. Examples include: creating short video clips via LOOM, a “daily bread dinner” story and cooking project, Godly Play sessions via Zoom, adapting an Easter “Ring-and-Run,” “Flat Jesus” narratives, or a Zoom game or art night.

Continue reading